Bennigan's Grill & Tavern
Appetizers ¦ Soup Shenanigans ¦ Lunch Combos ¦ Shandon St. Salads ¦ Gaelic Grill
Mulligan's Main Courses ¦ Luck-on-your-sides ¦ St. Paddy's Sandwiches ¦ Tavern Burgers
Kids Menu ¦ O' Yummy Deserts

APPETIZERS  

Cheese & Bacon Potato Skins $6.49
Thick potato skins filled with melted Colby cheese, bacon, and green onions. Served with a cool side of sour cream.
Buffalo Wings $5.79
Our world-famous tender chicken wings lightly fried and generously basted in our hot 'n' spicy sauce. Served with carrot and celery sticks and a side of bleu cheese dressing.
Fried Cheese $5.29
The Original! Our famous real Wisconsin mozzarella cheese sticks served with a side of zesty marinara sauce.
Golden Chicken Strips $5.99
Plump chicken tenderloins, double-breaded by hand, and fried until golden brown. Served with our very own Smoky Honey Dijon dressing on the side.
BROCCOLI BITES $5.39
A Bennigan's exclusive. We start with tender broccoli, mix it with bacon, onions, and cheese, roll it in bread crumbs, and serve it lightly fried with a side of Smoky Honey Dijon dressing.
ULTIMATE NACHOS $6.69
Crispy white corn tortilla chips piled mountain high with beef, beans, and melted Colby cheese, then topped with shredded lettuce, diced tomatoes, guacamole, sour cream, and sliced jalapenos. Makes other nachos feel inferior.
CHICKEN QUESADILLAS $6.69
Flour tortillas, stuffed with tender, spicy fajita chicken, chopped onions, ripe tomatoes, and real Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses, then grilled to perfection. Served with sides of guacamole, sour cream, and our special Fire-Roasted Salsa.
SOUTHWEST SAMPLER $8.99
Ultimate Nachos, Chicken Quesadillas, and our ever-so-tantalizing Southwest Eggrolls made with chicken, corn, black beans, mushrooms, rice, and cheese wrapped in a crispy shell. Served with sides of our Fire-Roasted Salsa and sweet Pineapple Pepper Cream Sauce.
SOUTHWEST GET TOGETHER SAMPLER $15.99
All the same great tastes of our favorite Southwest Sampler, only twice as much. It's the perfect starter for parties of three or more.
SPINACH-ARTICHOKE DIP WITH TOASTED FLATBREAD $6.99
We take tender artichokes and spinach, blend them together with three creamy cheeses, and serve it with toasted herb flatbread on the side.
BENNIGAN'S BEST SAMPLER $7.99
Crispy Cheese & Bacon Potato Skins, golden Fried Cheese, and our world-famous Buffalo Wings. Served with sides of marinara sauce, bleu cheese dressing, and sour cream.
BENNIGAN'S GET TOGETHER SAMPLER $14.99
Loaded with twice as much of the good stuff found on our Bennigan's Best Sample, it's ideal for parties of three of more.

SOUP SHENANIGANS  

SOUP O' THE DAY Bowl $3.59
Mug $2.69
Monday - Seven Bean & Bacon
Tuesday - Broccoli Cheese
Wednesday - Chicken Noodle
Thursday - Broccoli Cheese
Friday - Clam Chowder
ULTIMATE BAKED POTATO SOUP Bowl $3.79
Mug $2.79
This warm, creamy classic is guaranteed to leave you satisfied. Thick chunks of Irish potatoes, sprinkled with a medley of toppings including Colby cheese, bacon and green onions.
FRENCH ONION SOUP Bowl $3.89
The perfect complement to any meal, this rich, flavorful broth comes loaded with sauteed onions and topped with creamy, melted provolone cheese.

LUNCH COMBOS  

Available Monday through Friday 11am - 3 pm.

CHICAGO CHICKEN POT PIE $5.99
Home-style pot pie with thick chunks of tender chicken and garden vegetables in a creamy filling, topped with a flaky pastry. Served with a traditional salad.
1/2 CLASSIC SUB & SOUP $5.89
Enjoy a half of our Classic Club Sandwich with a hot cup of our Ultimate Baked Potato Soup, French Onion Soup, or Soup O' The Day.
SOUP & SALAD COMBINATION $5.49
Choose from a bowl of our Ultimate Baked Potato Skins, French Onion Soup, or Soup O' The Day. Served with your choice of a traditional or Caesar dinner salad.

SHANDON ST. SALADS  

All of our salads come complete with a fresh baked dinner roll and honey butter.

KILKENNY'S COUNTRY CHICKEN SALAD $6.99
We hand-bread tender chicken, fry it until golden brown, slice, and place atop a bed of fresh romaine and iceberg lettuce. Then add diced eggs, shredded Colby cheese, tomatoes, and bacon. Hungry yet? This salad's not complete without our special house dressing - Smoky Honey Dijon.
GRILLED CHICKEN CAESAR SALAD $6.99
Slices of grilled, mesquite-seasoned chicken breast served over crisp romaine lettuce and tossed in Caesar dressing. Topped with shredded parmesan cheese and croutons.
GRILLED SALMON CAESAR SALAD $8.99
We take a light, flaky 7 oz. salmon filet, season it with zesty Cajun spices, and grill it to perfection. Then we serve it over crisp romaine lettuce tossed in Caesar dressing and top it with croutons and shredded parmesan cheese.
BENNIGAN'S CLUB SALAD $6.79
Think of it as the salad lovers' version of the Classic Club Sandwich. Turkey, Colby and Monterey Jack cheeses, cucumber, bacon, and tomatoes. served with your choice of dressing.
CAJUN CHICKEN SALAD $6.89
Slices of Cajun-spiced, charbroiled chicken breast served over salad greens with Colby cheese and diced tomatoes. Served with your choice of dressing.
DINNER SALAD $2.99
Choose from our traditional or Caesar salad.
Top your salad with one of our delicious salad dressings:
House - Smoky Honey Dijon, Oil & Vinegar, Ranch, Thousand Island, Honey French, Bleu Cheese, Italian, Caesar, Low-Cal Italian, Fat-Free Peppercorn Ranch, Fat-Free Honey Dijon

GAELIC GRILL  

"OH, BABY" BACK RIBS $14.99
We're talking a full slab of our thick, juicy, grilled-to-tender perfection choice ribs basted in our tangy barbecue sauce. Comes with seasoned French fries, creamy cole slaw, and a way to make your mouth water at first sight.
NEW WORLD FAJITAS $9.69
One bite of our fajitas, and you'll swear the Irish invented them. We grill your choice of marinated chicken breast or tender beef together with onions and peppers, and serve them with warm tortillas, guacamole, sour cream, Colby cheese, lettuce, and tomatoes.
Chicken Fajitas 9.69
Top Sirloin Fajitas 9.69
Combo Fajitas 9.69
HEALTH CLUB GRILLED SHRIMP $9.79
Juicy, succulent shrimp lightly seasoned and grilled to savory perfection. Served with sides of Rice O'Riley and Bailey's Broccoli, or grilled shrimp plate is definitely big on taste. 6 grams of fat.
O' CAJUN GRILLED SEAFOOD PLATTER $13.99
This tasty platter comes with a spicy, caramelized crabcake, a 7 oz. flaky grilled salmon filet, and a generous skewer of 8 grilled shrimp served on a bed of Rice O'Riley with a side of cole slaw. And to top it all off, it comes with a side of our very own Remoulade sauce, a zesty New Orleans classic.

MULLIGAN'S MAIN COURSES  

Add a Bennigan's Dinner Salad or dinner Caesar Salad for $1.89

GOLDEN CHICKEN STRIPS* $7.99
We select plump chicken tenderloins, double-bread them by hand, and deep fry until golden brown. Then serve with our very own Smoky Honey Dijon dressing for dipping. Accompanied by your choice of two delicious side items.
CLASSIC SEAFOOD PLATTER $10.99
Golden-fried shrimp, a deviled crab cake, and lightly fried North Atlantic cod served with jalapeno tartar sauce and cocktail sauce for dipping. Complete with our crispy, seasoned French fries and cole slaw.
HEALTH CLUB STIR-FRY 8.29
We take a medley of vegetables and stir-fry them with our tantalizing Asian sauce and serve over a bed of fluffy rice. Try it with tender chicken or just vegetables. Never before has eating healthy been so tasty.
TRALEE BAY FISH 'N' CHIPS $7.59
We start with the same North Atlantic cod celebrated by the fishermen of Tralee Bay. Flaky cod battered by hand, then fried until golden, and served with jalapeno tartar sauce and cocktail sauce for dipping. Complete with our crispy, seasoned French fries and cole slaw.
CHICKEN FRIED STEAK $8.29
Built for bigger appetites, this tender steak is deep fried then smothered with a rich cream gravy.
SMOTHERED CHICKEN $8.99
Mouth-watering chicken piled high with nothing but the good stuff. We're talking two tender chicken breasts smothered with bacon, sauteed onions, mushrooms, and provolone cheese. Served with your choice of two delicious side items
TAVERN SHRIMP $13.79
This delicious catch of twelve shrimp is butterflied and lightly crusted in oriental breadcrumbs and fried 'til golden. Served with our jalapeno tarter sauce and your choice of two side items.
CHICKEN TERIYAKI $8.59
We start by marinating two plump chicken breasts in our tangy, sweet teriyaki sauce. Then we charbroil them to tender, juicy perfection and serve with your choice of two delicious side items. A fortunate choice.
HEALTH CLUB CHICKEN PLATTER $8.59
Two fajita-marinated chicken breasts charbroiled and served with a side of Rice O'Riley and Bailey's Broccoli. 9 grams of fat.
RILEY'S RIBEYE $13.99
A mouth-watering 12 oz. USDA Choice ribeye marinated in our sweet soy ginger sauce and grilled just the way you like - thick and juicy.
TAVERN T-BONE $15.99
A generously cut 16 oz. USDA Choice T-Bone charbroiled to order and topped with our very own barbecue butter and green onions.
IRISH-AMERICAN TOP SIRLOIN $12.99
A full-flavored favorite. We grill this succulent 10 oz. USDA Choice center cut top sirloin to absolute perfection.
SMOTHERED NEW YORK STRIP $14.99
Our 10 oz. USDA Choice center cut strip is aged to perfection, charbroiled to order, and smothered with sauteed onions, mushrooms, bacon, and cheddar cheese.
STEAK AND SHRIMP COMBO $15.99
A tender 10 oz. USDA Choice center cut top sirloin steak grilled to your liking and a skewer of succulent Fire-Roasted Salsa Shrimp. Served with our zesty Rire-Roasted Salsa and your choice of two delicious side items.
THE DUBLINER $16.99
For hearty appetites the size of Ireland's capital. We combine our juicy 12 oz. Riley's Ribeye with a catch of Tavern Shrimp that's butterflied, coated in oriental breadcrumbs, lightly fried and accompanied by jalapeno tarter sauce for dipping. Served with a baked potato and your choice of toppings.

LUCK-ON-YOUR-SIDES  

BAILEY'S BROCCOLI $1.59
Steamed tender broccoli crowns.
RICE O'RILEY $1.59
Seasoned rice pilaf mixed with a bounty of sauteed carrots, onions, bell peppers, and cilantro.
CORN & BLACK BEANS $1.59
Buttery corn and black beans sprinkled with jalapenos and red and green peppers.
DINNER ROLLS $2.19
A basket of fresh baked dinner rolls served with honey butter.
COLE SLAW $1.59
A creamy, slightly sweet favorite brimming goodness.
CINNAMON APPLES $1.59
Baked apples flavored with raisins and cinnamon
FRENCH FRIES $2.29
Our crispy fries seasoned to perfection. One bite and you'll agree they make a tasty addition to any meal.
THE GREAT BAKED POTATO $2.29
Achieve potato greatness by adding as many or as few toppings as you like. Served piping hot, this potato is a masterpiece created by you.
GOOD GARLIC MASHED POTATOES $1.59
These creamy mashed potatoes are far from ordinary. Roasted garlic adds just the right kick to these too-good-to-be-true potatoes.

ST.PADDY'S SANDWICHES  

Our sandwiches are so good, we named them after a Saint. Made with only the finest ingredients, our St. Paddy's sandwiches come with an order of crispy, seasoned French fries and a pickle spear. One bite, and you'll be in heaven.

THE MOTE CRISTO $7.29
This is the sandwich all other sandwiches aspire to be. It's stacked with ham, turkey, Swiss and American cheeses on wheat bread, then battered and fried 'til golden. Dusted with powdered sugar and accompanied by red raspberry preserves, you'll love this Bennigan's classic.
THE CLASSIC CLUB $5.99
The classic combination of turkey, ham, bacon, Swiss and American cheeses with lettuce, tomato, and mayonnaise on whole grain bread.
TURKEY O'TOOLE $6.29
Served hot on our unique pretzel roll, a healthy portion of thinly sliced, tender turkey breast, melted Swiss cheese, and Smoky Honey Dijon is a timeless treat. So good, you'll want to gobble it up.
BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH $6.69
A tender, fried chicken breast topped with our special hot 'n' spicy sauce, bale cheese dressing, lettuce, tomato, and red onion served on your choice of a wheat or white peppered brioche bun.
O' PHILLY CHEESE STEAK SANDWICH $6.89
This Philly-style steak is loaded with onions, mushrooms, and provolone cheese, then served on a toasty golden Philly roll
BACON & CHEESE SANDWICH $6.69
A juicy chicken breast topped with melted cheddar cheese, crisp bacon slices, mayonnaise, lettuce, tomato, and red onion served on your choice of a wheat or white peppered brioche bun.
THE FRENCH-DIP SANDWICH $6.89
Thinly sliced lean roast beef and melted provolone cheese piled high on a toasted Philly roll. Served with warm au jus for dipping.
HEALTH CLUB CHICKEN SANDWICH $6.49
A plump, juicy charbroiled chicken breast topped with lettuce, tomato, red onion, and Fat-Free Honey Dijon. Served on a toasted wheat peppered brioche bun, with a side of carrot and celery sticks and Fat-Free Peppercorn Ranch dressing. 9 grams of fat.

TAVERN BURGERS  

As inviting as the taverns that share their names, our Tavern Burgers are made with a hearty 1/2 pound of USDA Choice chuck. Served with crispy, seasoned French fries and your choice of a wheat or white peppered brioche bun with lettuce, tomato, red onion, and a pickle spear, it's the taste everybody's getting together for. And don't forget to add bacon to any burger for only $.99.
Boca burger patty may be substituted for beef in any of our burgers.

THE AMERICAN $6.19
This classic burger comes with American cheese, mustard, and pickles.
JOHN'S BACON $6.49
A favorite at John's pub, this juicy bacon cheeseburger combines all his favorite tastes into one great burger - cheddar cheese, barbecue sauce, bacon, and mustard.
THE BIG IRISH $8.99
This unbelievably tasty burger was inspired by the big stories told by locals at The Big Irish Tavern. We're talking two 1/2 pound patties, two slices of American cheese, mustard, pickles, and an extra bun in the middle. It's almost too good to believe.
THE MUSHROOM $6.49
Topped with sauteed mushrooms and onions, thick melted provolone cheese and mayonnaise, it's definitely a favorite.
SEAN O' FLANNERY'S WHEELHOUSE $6.49
A juicy, mouth-watering burger topped with a savory fried cheese wheel, fresh parmesan cheese, and zesty marinara sauce.
BOCCA $6.19
This delicious Boca burger packs mouth-watering great taste that will satisfy without slowing you down. Made from nutritious, protien-filled soy and topped with american cheese, mustard and pickles.

KID'S MEALS  

All of our kids meals include a soft drink, crispy French fries, and
our signature clover sugar cookie with green sprinkles

BILLY THE KID BURGER $3.89
A kid-sized hamburger with American cheese served on a pretzel roll.
GRILLED CHEESE $3.39
Two pieces of wheat bread grilled with American cheese.
HOT DIGGITY DOG $3.59
An Oscar Mayer hot dog served on a bun.
CHICKEN-A-LITTLE $3.89
Golden Chicken Strips.
MAC 'N' CHEESE $3.39
A portion of creamy macaroni and cheese

O' YUMMY DESSERTS  

BROWNIE BOTTOM PIE $3.79
A chewy chocolate fudge brownie topped with a creamy scoop of Vanilla ice cream and smothered with rich hot fudge.
DEATH BY CHOCOLATE $3.99
A Bennigan's original. It's Dutch Chocolate ice cream and nutty Rocky Road ice cream, mixed with Twix Cookie Bars, then dipped in a rich chocolate sauce. Served on top of a crumbled chocolate cookie crust with a side of hot chocolate topping, it's killer.
MARY McCLARY'S VERY BERRY PIE $4.29
A McClary family secret. Packed with wild berries, this pie truly is a slice of heaven. Served warm with a scoop of Vanilla ice cream and topped with a raspberry sauce. Berry delicious!
WHITE CHOCOLATE CHILL-OUT $3.99
We take White Chocolate Almond ice cream and Vanilla Chocolate Chip ice cream, mix them with crumbled Oreos cookie crust. Then dip it in white chocolate and serve with a side of hot chocolate sauce.
BENNIGAN'S CHEESECAKE BY Eli's $3.99
This rich, creamy cheesecake was prepared exclusively for Bennigan's by the culinary experts at Eli's. And since it's a Bennigan's Health Club item, you get all the great taste with only 13 grams of fat. Experience it plain or topped with juicy strawberries today
ABBEY'S APPLE SIZZLER $3.79
A generous skillet lined with an oatmeal walnut crumb cookie crust and piled high with hot cinnamon apples and raisins. Topped with Cinnamon ice cream and caramel sauce.